Whether you're heading to a nearby river, a club pond or a gravel pit in the next village: hardly any lure angler sets out without a large and colourful selection of soft lures, the ones that give every lure box that unmistakable smell of soft plastic. Yet very few anglers have a solid grasp of when to reach for which colour.
The Right Questions to Ask When Choosing a Colour
First, let go of the temptation to put yourself in the predator's place. The question shouldn't be: 'Which of these soft lures would I bite on if I were a pike?' No — choosing the right colour demands a more complex line of thinking. What you really need to consider is how a given colour is perceived by the fish at the depth you're fishing, under the prevailing light conditions, and which colour will ensure the lure is actually seen.
To explore that question, it's worth noting that fish eyes are, in terms of their biological structure, broadly similar to our own. Colour vision in fish is therefore probably not all that different from ours.
Reading and Weighing Up the Water
To work out what a lure looks like down on the bottom of the water I'm fishing, I pay close attention to four key factors — all of which determine how much available light actually reaches the bottom:
- Light intensity (sunny vs. overcast),
- sun angle (overhead vs. low on the horizon during the morning and evening hours),
- water clarity (clear vs. coloured)
- and water depth (shallow vs. deep).
From how these factors interact, I build a picture of the light conditions at the bottom. Bear in mind that the factors can also influence one another. When I'm fishing at great depth, for instance, water clarity becomes all the more significant. Water colour could be added to the equation too, but I want to keep this guide straightforward so it's as useful as possible for as many of you as possible.
How Soft Lure Colours Behave Underwater
Once you have a sense of the conditions, you just need to know which colours remain visible to the predator at any given residual light level. As a rule of thumb: the greater the depth, the more coloured the water, the worse the weather, and the shallower the angle at which light hits the surface — the more sunlight is absorbed or reflected before it ever reaches the bottom. And that means you need colours that stay visible in whatever light remains.
Which Colours Can Still Be Seen in Low Light?
Red is the first colour to be absorbed in water — red lures lose their colour fastest below the surface — followed by orange, yellow, green, blue, and finally violet. Ultraviolet rays penetrate the deepest by a considerable margin.
Those persistent UV rays can work in our favour on the bank: fluorescent colours absorb UV and so fluo lures remain visible for far longer even in the worst light conditions.
Since this physics-based approach won't be everyone's cup of tea, let me get more practical and give you a few examples of proven colours and products.
Examples of High-Visibility Soft Lures
The less light I expect at the bottom, the brighter and bolder the colours I rely on — right through to neon fluo lures. Here, all that matters is that the lure is spotted by the predator. Good examples are Pinky, Sheriff and Möhrchen from Lieblingsköder.
Mr. White and Mr. Black from LK's Gold Edition also perform very well in coloured water, because white — and surprisingly black too — can still be perceived by the fish even in the worst visibility, unlike many other colours.
Ideal Soft Lures in Brighter Light
As light levels at the bottom increase, I shift to slightly darker colours. Green, for example, is an excellent choice for moderate bottom-light conditions.
For middling visibility in the water, I'm particularly fond of colour blends such as Captain and Wasabi — Lieblingsköder has struck a great balance between standout appeal and a natural look with both of these.
The clearer and brighter the water, the more confident I am that my lure will be seen regardless. At that point I place more emphasis on natural colours and attractive lure movement. In good visibility my colour choice usually starts with the 'true colours' of likely prey species. Whisky as a ruffe imitation and Sunny as a whitefish imitation — both from Lieblingsköder, and both found in the palettes of most successful soft lure shapes — are ones I'd strongly recommend when the light is good.
Experimenting Is Key
That said, the range of workable colours is wider in good light, so don't be afraid to try a few options when the fish aren't playing ball. It also helps explain why low-light conditions are generally good for lure fishing: when there's little light, a bright lure stands out from natural prey simply by being visible at all. In good light, on the other hand, you need to make your lure attractive through the most appealing presentation you can manage — which is naturally harder when you're up against real baitfish.
Don't leave your lure choice to chance. With a bit of thought and patience, a little trial and error will lead you to the right soft plastic on the right jig head — and even less experienced anglers will find themselves landing fish more often than not!
Tight lines to you all!
Daniel































